Project

Photo: Andrés Ángel / AIDA

Supporting Cajamarca’s fight to defend its territory from mining

Cajamarca is a town in the mountains of central Colombia, often referred to as "Colombia’s pantry” due to its great agricultural production. In addition to fertile lands, fed by rivers and 161 freshwater springs, the municipality features panoramic views of gorges and cloud forests. The main economic activities of its population—agriculture and tourism—depend on the health of these natural environments.

The fertile lands of Cajamarca are also rich in minerals, for which AngloGold Ashanti has descended on the region. The international mining conglomerate seeks to develop one of the world’s largest open-pit gold mines in the area.  Open-pit mining is particularly damaging to the environment as extracting the metal involves razing green areas and generating huge amounts of potentially toxic waste

The project, appropriately named La Colosa, would be the second largest of its kind in Latin America and the first open-pit gold mine in Colombia. The toxic elements that an operation of that magnitude would leave behind could contaminate the soil, air, rivers and groundwater.

In addition, storms, earthquakes, or simple design errors could easily cause the dams storing the toxic mining waste to rupture. The collapse of similar tailings dams in Peru and Brazil in recent years has caused catastrophic social and environmental consequences.

On March 26, 2017, in a popular referendum, 98 percent of the voters of Cajamarca said “No” to mining in their territory, effectively rejecting the La Colosa project. AIDA is proud to have contributed to that initiative. But even with this promising citizen-led victory, much work remains.

 


Diálogo académico sobre riesgos de presas de relaves en Ecuador.
Mining

Tailings dams: Insights from science to address their risks

Mining begins by removing vegetation and topsoil. Next, miners excavate to extract metals and minerals from the subsoil. This process generates a large amount of waste or tailings: 200 kilograms of waste for every kilogram of economically valuable material in a high-efficiency mine.This waste is a mixture of rock debris, water, and chemical compounds used in mining operations. But where does this waste end up?They end up in tailings dams, permanent storage sites for mining waste located in the same areas where mining operations take place.Despite being critical infrastructure—since their failure or collapse can seriously harm the environment and people—prior, transparent discussion regarding tailings dams and their risks is rare among authorities, mining companies, and affected communities.To address this gap, on July 22 and 23, AIDA—in partnership with the Universidad Técnica Particular de Loja (UTPL) and the Find an Expert in Mining (FAIME) project—organized an inclusive event in the city of Loja, Ecuador, featuring academic dialogue and scientific outreach on the management of risks associated with tailings dams.The event brought together people from different regions and technical experts from Latin America for a diverse dialogue on managing mining waste.This initiative is part of our efforts to promote science—including traditional knowledge—as a fundamental and accessible tool for defending territories and everyone’s right to a healthy environment.Below, we share key information and insights from the event on tailings dams and the risks associated with them. Concerns and uncertainties surrounding tailings damsAll crushed, chemically processed rock—from which valuable metals and minerals have been extracted, as well as rock with no economic value to the industry—remains in the area in tailings dams.During mine operations, after mine closure, and in perpetuity, mining companies must ensure that these infrastructure systems completely isolate waste from the environment. Exposure to this mixture of mining waste has significant socio-environmental impacts. This raises concerns and questions that are rarely discussed, including:The dam's dimensions: How many metric tons of waste will be stored?  Location: Where will this waste be allowed to be stored indefinitely?Isolation: How can we ensure that rocks containing toxic substances and heavy metals do not affect the soil, water sources, biodiversity, and people?Safety: How can we ensure infrastructure does not endanger people's lives or the environment they depend on? The event highlighted that science, as a tool for territorial protection, makes it possible to identify the threats posed by tailings dams, describe them, and delve deeper into the specific risks that must be managed in each territory.This is because those who have—or may potentially have—these so-called environmental "liabilities" in perpetuity where there was once a road, a forest, or a river face many unanswered questions that must be addressed.Even for experts in related technical fields, tailings dams are challenging structures. Those who work closely with this issue can confirm that complete or freely available data is not always available to monitor these structures throughout their entire life cycle. Several factors help us understand, for each specific project, aspects related to the design, construction, operation, monitoring, closure, and post-closure of tailings dams, as well as the effects of climate change and their resilience.In most projects, this information is confidential and may be reviewed only by mining companies and government regulatory agencies. Challenging the usual narrativesGovernments and companies often claim that they apply the highest standards at every stage of mining operations, but say little or nothing about the risks that mining waste poses to the environment and people.Unfortunately, many generations have suffered disasters caused by the collapse of these dams:2019: Brumadinho, Minas Gerais, Brazil.2014: Mount Polley, British Columbia, Canada.2010: Las Palmas, Maule, Chile.2010: Huachocolpa, Huancavelica, Peru.1965: El Cobre, Valparaíso, Chile. These disasters were not foreseen despite monitoring efforts, nor were they prevented. While they may seem distant, the surrounding communities bear the brunt of the human losses and environmental damage. In addition to these well-known catastrophes, these structures collapse every year around the world. A chronology of major tailings dam failures dating back to 1960 is available on the Wise Uranium website. A diverse and fruitful academic dialogueDiscussing the risks associated with tailings dams was key to understanding the concerns of those who already live near these structures. It was also important to recognize that with every new metal mining project, new communities will be forced to coexist with these tailings ponds. Regardless of where they are or may be located, understanding and managing these risks is essential.The event in Ecuador showed us that dams exist in many forms, both on and off the continent (in Canada, Chile, Brazil, Ecuador, and Peru). It helped us learn more about standards, community-based monitoring systems, restoration efforts, and demands around the risks involved.In working groups made up of experts—both technical specialists and members of the public—we shared knowledge, experiences, questions, and a few answers. We built alliances to continue spreading information and building a community that we hope will grow.One of the most striking discussions centered on tolerable risk. Even when we know the risks and manage them, they remain. How much risk can we tolerate, and are we willing to? The answers vary depending on whether they come from industry or certain governments. But if we focus on the populations at risk, the answer is NONE. Of course. Who among us, in the name of development and the energy transition, would leave their home right now to live next to a tailings dam? Using science to renew hope and bridge gapsWe heard stories from communities where water quality has been affected by metal mining projects. In these cases, for example, using science as a tool for territorial defense means maintaining a timeline of water quality parameters—monitored by the community—to show companies and authorities that water quality has changed and to demand immediate action. It is also reflected in directly affected communities that propose specific studies and monitoring initiatives for their territories, carry them out, and use the results to strengthen decision-making and legal action.However, for many communities, developing scientific studies tailored to their realities remains a pipe dream. Funding gaps and a lack of technical tools limit communities’ ability to use the best available science to defend their territories and livelihoods. That is why AIDA and FAIME seek to connect consultants and technical teams with communities and the organizations that support them, to help ensure that the best available science is no longer a privilege. Thank youWe at AIDA would like to thank the experts and representatives from various communities in the region for their participation in this academic dialogue. We will continue to foster these opportunities and find ways to ensure that communities affected by mining can use science as a useful and effective tool to defend their rights.  

Read more

Vista panorámica del páramo de Sumapaz en Colombia.
Freshwater Sources, Mining

Páramos = water = life

Páramos are high-mountain ecosystems that capture water from fog and supply it to the lowlands. They lie between the upper limit of the Andean forest (about 3,000 meters above sea level) and the glaciers or permanent snowfields of the mountains (about 4,500 meters above sea level).Typically, páramos can be found in tropical regions near the equator, especially along the Andes mountain range.In Latin America, páramos cover more than 30,000 km2. South America is home to more than 80% of the world’s páramos, and Colombia accounts for 50% of them.The páramos are not isolated; rather, they form a high-mountain system that maintains ecological connections with other biomes and ecosystems, extending beyond national borders. In the Andean region, they form a corridor known as the "string of pearls," stretching from the Cordillera de Mérida in Venezuela, across Colombia and Ecuador, to the Huancabamba Depression in northern Peru.There, the water retained by low-altitude wetlands gradually flows downward, forming streams and rivers that flow down to the coast or the Amazon basin.Because of their interconnectedness, the páramos also serve as natural bridges or "springboards" for the migration and dispersal of species. Their conservation, therefore, cannot be limited to specific areas; it must extend to protecting the ecological, biological, and cultural relationships they share with other ecosystems. The importance of protecting the páramosWe must protect the páramos because they are essential to sustaining life. Among other reasons, this is because:They feed key watersheds, which in turn support agricultural and livestock systems that contribute to the population's food supply. They are the primary source of water for more than 85 million people. In Colombia, these ecosystems supply 70% of the freshwater consumed in major cities.They are home to a unique biodiversity: more than 3,370 plant species and 250 animal species. Among the endemic species found there are the frailejón (a plant with hairy leaves that trap moisture from the fog and regulate water), the Andean condor, the mountain tapir (or Andean tapir), and the spectacled bear.They serve as living spaces and homes for rural and indigenous communities. According to the 2018 páramo census, more than 76,000 people in Colombia live in the country’s páramo ecosystems. Furthermore, their stunning natural beauty drives nature tourism, thereby sustaining local ways of life.They are extraordinary natural carbon sinks and are indispensable allies in mitigating the climate crisis. They can sequester up to ten times more carbon dioxide per square meter than a tropical forest. In specific areas of a páramo, such as peat bogs, carbon sequestration can reach 2,000 metric tons.   Photo: Aztlec Flickr (Creative Commons).What threats must we protect the páramos from?Despite their great importance, the páramos currently face several threats. One is the climate crisis, which is raising ambient temperatures; because these ecosystems are located high in the mountains, they have no cooler thermal zones to migrate to.On the other hand, extensive livestock ranching and agriculture—particularly potato farming—affect considerable areas of páramos. Deforestation or reforestation with non-native species also endangers them, as does a lack of knowledge about their importance and characteristics.And mining is undoubtedly one of the greatest threats to these ecosystems. Due to their geological formation, these ecosystems contain large quantities of minerals and metals, such as gold and silver. The mining industry poses serious risks to the páramos because:It extracts large volumes of water and builds infrastructure on wetlands, reducing their ability to regulate water flows, and can cause pollution from mercury and other toxic substances, leading to species loss and affecting water quality and availability in low-lying areas.Underground mining can alter groundwater flow dynamics through dewatering processes designed to prevent tunnel collapse. This can lower the water table, cause land subsidence, and dry up water sources, among other impacts.It removes vegetation cover and organic soil, degrading fragile ecosystems such as the páramos, weakening their role as natural carbon sinks, and releasing stored carbon.Its impacts can last in perpetuity—for centuries or millennia—timeframes that cannot be predicted with certainty. Tailings dams and other infrastructure (tailings piles or dumps) where mining waste ends up, for example, have effects that persist indefinitely because they were not designed to be dismantled. Learn more about the true cost of mining in the páramos. The iconic case of the Santurbán páramo in ColombiaThe Santurbán case reflects the socio-environmental conflicts that arise from corporate efforts to establish mining operations in páramos, as well as from citizens’ efforts to protect these ecosystems and the life they sustain. Photo: Alberto Peña Kay. Located in the heart of the Eastern Cordillera of the Colombian Andes, in the departments of Santander and Norte de Santander, the Santurbán páramo covers 129,743 hectares and is home to 57 lagoons, 457 plant species, and 293 vertebrate species.Santurbán is home to mineral deposits—primarily gold, but also silver and copper—that have attracted foreign mining conglomerates for decades, which have sought to establish large-scale projects in the ecosystem, threatening to degrade it.This has raised concerns among the population that relies on the Santurbán water sources—more than two million people—who have mobilized to defend water, their land, and life.The Committee for the Defense of Water and the Santurbán Páramo has led these efforts. This coalition of environmental advocates, supported by AIDA and other civil society organizations, has thwarted the mining industry’s ongoing attempts. The defense of Santurbán has included litigation and national and international advocacy. Learn more about the effort to protect the Santurbán páramo. Protecting Latin America's páramosAs with Santurbán in Colombia, indigenous peoples, rural communities, and citizens in other countries in the region are using legal strategies to protect the Andean páramos.Also in Colombia, rural communities in Cajamarca, in the department of Tolima, succeeded in rejecting the La Colosa mining project—which would have involved gold mining in the Los Nevados páramo region—through a public referendum. They are currently defending the referendum's validity and the páramo demarcation in court.In Ecuador, the Kichwa Saraguro indigenous people are pursuing legal action to protect more than 27,000 hectares of the Fierro Urku páramo, which were granted as mining concessions for gold, silver, and copper without prior consultation. At the same time, they are demanding compliance with a protective order that suspended the Loma Larga mining project in the Quimsacocha páramo until prior consultation is guaranteed and environmental impact studies are conducted.In partnership with communities and allied organizations, AIDA works to protect the páramos and other ecosystems that sustain life in Latin America. 

Read more

Panel solar en una comunidad de Cuetzalan, México
Climate Change, Human Rights

Self-generation: How to democratize access to energy

In the traditional and dominant model, electricity is generated by large power plants and distributed through extensive grids that make up an electric power system. These activities are the exclusive domain of large electric companies, whether privately or government-owned.Therefore, the current energy system, based on fossil fuels—coal, natural gas, and oil—is not only one of the main causes of the global climate crisis, but it is also inequitable because it is concentrated in the hands of a few, in addition to limiting access to resources and public participation in decision-making.This requires that the energy transition involves not only a shift in the energy mix but also the creation of a new energy system that—among other things—enables democratized access to energy from clean, renewable sources.Energy self-generation, as a decentralized production model, is an opportunity to move in that direction. What does democratic access to energy mean?Energy is necessary for people to have access to better food, clean water, job opportunities, education, and other rights. Therefore, energy is also a right and a prerequisite for ensuring the enjoyment of other human rights.Energy democracy is both a principle and a movement that seeks to ensure that energy decisions—how it is generated, who generates it, and who benefits from it—are in the hands of the people rather than concentrated in the hands of large corporations or elites, prioritizing the use of clean and renewable energy sources as well as decentralized systems, with a focus on social justice.Therefore, democratic access to energy entails:Community control of energy resources.Citizen participation in energy planning.Equitable distribution of benefits. This contrasts with traditional centralized systems—often monopolistic—that have led to inequities, such as communities paying high electricity rates or suffering the impacts of large-scale electricity generation, yet having no say in the decisions that affect them.In Latin America, the active involvement of indigenous, rural, and traditional communities in energy projects is seen as a cornerstone for achieving a socially and environmentally just transition, closing energy access gaps, and strengthening energy democracy.In this regard, energy self-generation embodies energy democracy, as it allows entire communities to make their own energy decisions and reclaim control over key links in the electricity value chain, such as generation and management. What is energy self-generation?Self-generation is a decentralized model of electricity production that relies on locally available clean and renewable energy sources (such as solar, hydropower, or wind). This approach is used in projects that are often small-scale and can be used individually or collectively to meet energy needs in urban or rural areas, including those far from distribution grids.It is a model that enables progress, at the local level, toward reducing greenhouse gas emissions—which exacerbate the climate crisis—without repeating the extractivist model. It recognizes the right of communities to generate their own energy to meet their needs and, at the same time, helps reduce energy poverty and dependence on centralized power grids.Energy self-generation can take two forms:Distributed generation: A small-scale self-generation system connected to nearby distribution grids to feed surplus energy into the grid.Off-grid systems: A closed-loop self-generation system disconnected from distribution grids. In this model, users are no longer passive participants but instead play an active role in generating and managing energy wherever they are. A self-generating individual or community both produces and consumes energy. Examples of energy self-generation in Latin AmericaAcross the continent, success stories in implementing the self-generation model are strengthening the regional movement for energy democratization. Here are a few examples:Mexico - "Energy for the Yeknemilis (Good Living)." A community initiative implemented in the Northeastern Highlands of Puebla to promote local energy sovereignty through the installation of photovoltaic systems in community spaces.Colombia - Community solar project on Isla Fuerte. Installation of a solar microgrid with batteries (150 kW peak and 348 kWh of storage), not connected to the National Interconnected System, capable of providing continuous electricity to the 250 households on the Caribbean island.Brazil - Percília e Lúcio Renewable Energy Cooperative. A community initiative founded by the NGO Revolusolar and developed by residents of the Morro da Babilônia and Chapéu Mangueira favelas in Rio de Janeiro. Solar panels were installed there, reducing electricity rates by more than 50%.Chile - Curicó Electric Power Supply Cooperative. A community-based initiative operating in the Maule Region that installs solar panels to supply electricity to rural grids and community facilities. Challenges for energy self-generationDespite the progress made, the widespread and effective implementation of this model faces significant challenges on the continent. The main ones are:Inadequate regulation (complex or insufficient). Often, a country’s domestic regulations make it difficult or impossible to implement such schemes. This is due to limitations on the number of megawatts (MW) that can be generated, complex contractual requirements, or a lack of appropriate legal structures.Limited financing. Many low-income households cannot afford the upfront cost of solar panels or other technologies. Government support or loans for these projects are scarce. The risk is that self-generation will be concentrated among those with the financial means to implement it, thereby excluding the segments of the population most affected by energy poverty.Inefficient electrical infrastructure. Local grids often lack the capacity or technical capabilities to integrate energy generated by decentralized sources, limiting the ability to take advantage of surplus energy feed-in. Furthermore, the need for storage systems to address the variability of renewable energy sources, as well as the lack of grid backup, increases project costs. Energy self-generation: A solid path toward a just transitionThe pursuit of equitable access to energy through tools such as energy self-generation is consistent with the need to ensure that the energy transition puts people at the center and prioritizes improving their living conditions as its ultimate goal.Electricity generation models designed by and for communities are an important means of ensuring access to affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy for everyone.Because discussing a just energy transition means reclaiming energy as a tool to meet human needs in the context of inequities and finite resources. Learn more about a just energy transition in Latin America.  

Read more