Project

Photo: #RealChile 

Protecting Patagonian Seas from Salmon Farms

The Straight of Magellan in Chilean Patagonia (or Magallanes, as it’s known in Spanish) hosts the largest number of natural protected areas in the country. Permanent snow feeds the idyllic landscape, which has been shaped by glaciers, lakes, rivers and seas. Within its bounds live protected species—blue whales, sperm whales, Magellanic penguins, elephant seals, leatherback turtles, and southern and Chilean dolphins.

The cold waters of this far corner of the world are pristine; this makes them more sensitive to high-impact human activities. And now they’re being stressed by the arrival of salmon farms, which have already caused severe environmental damage in regions further north.

In Chile, the salmon industry uses harmful techniques and operates without proper regulation. Its rapid growth has overwhelmed coastal waters, filling them with huge amounts of antibiotics, chemicals, and salmon feces. These pollutants have led to partial or, in some places, complete lack of oxygen in the water, threating all forms of marine life.

Large salmon farms in the Magallanes region are already causing big damage. According to a government audit, more than half of the salmon farms operating there are affecting the availability of oxygen in the water, a condition that did not occur prior to their arrival.

Partners:

Latest News


Vista aérea de la Reserva Nacional Kawésqar, Chile

The Kawésqar people and the defense of their "maritorio" in Chile

By Liliana Ávila and Cristina Lux*   A little over a month ago, the community Kawésqar Grupos Familiares Nómades del Mar sent us a very special invitation. The appointment was near the sea, near their territory, or more precisely, near their "maritorio", a place of islands, islets and archipelagos. There, the borders between sea and land are blurred and the trees grow sideways, adapted to the strong winds. The maritorio is a concept and also a way of inhabiting and understanding the world. It evokes the image of "territory", but seen from and in the sea. As a concept, it emerged in the context of what is known as nisology, or the study of islands. The place we visited is located in the fjords of Magallanes, the southernmost region of Chile, about two hours from Punta Arenas, the regional capital. The Kawésqar people tell us that less than a century ago, this maritorio was their home. There, their grandfathers and grandmothers sailed among the fjords, built their canoes, fished and dived. They went into the icy sea without special neoprene suits, protected with sea lion oil, and there they learned the secrets that its depths held. In the midst of fjords, winds and intense climates, these people developed their own systems of thought and life. But the lives of the Kawésqar have changed radically in recent decades. They tell us so.  The vast territory that previous generations inhabited for centuries is now enclosed. The process of eradication has been accompanied by the commercialization of the land, the creation of extensive pastures and, more recently, the development and expansion of the salmon farming industry. Industrial salmon production has serious and lasting impacts on marine ecosystems. The communities of Kawésqar are well aware of this.  Salmon is an exotic and carnivorous species for Chile, raised in huge farms: hectares of cages in the sea. The introduction of exotic species (which threaten native species), the excessive use of antibiotics, salmon escapes, the generation of waste, the treatment of large quantities of dead salmon, the excessive discharge of organic matter into the sea, and the generation of anaerobic environments (total or partial loss of oxygen necessary for life to thrive) are just some of the impacts of salmon farming in Chile. These impacts not only accumulate in the waters and on the seabed, but also penetrate the lives of the Kawésqar communities. The maritorio that their grandfathers and grandmothers sailed is now a desecrated space. The processes of reconstructing their identity, the appropriation of sacred places and the rites that are part of their collective memory have been affected by the development of an industry that sees the sea only as a space of economic exploitation and not as the sacred place where, in the not so distant past, men and women developed their worldviews and ways of life. Despite everything, the Kawésqar are a living people who meet, who gather around the sea and discuss strategies to rebuild their cultural fabric. They also come together to honor their grandfathers and grandmothers, to activate the genetic memory that connects them to the sea, to dive into its waters and fight for a salmon-free sea and for a country that recognizes the cultural diversity that runs through its history. We also connect with the legacy of the Kawésqar. Swimming with people from the community in these seas that have been navigated for thousands of years allowed us to look out a window that blurs the present and shows us alternatives. A present that allows life and coexistence with the sea, its ecosystems and its balance. Their struggle— supported by AIDA, the NGO FIMA, Greenpeace and many other organizations— has borne fruit. It has highlighted the impact of salmon farming in Chile and the need to end our dependence on it. But the challenges are still enormous. Salmon farming continues to ravage the seas inside and outside protected areas, in the most remote areas of Patagonia, occupying spaces that were once shared by all the peoples and creatures that inhabited the territory. Meanwhile, the people of Kawésqar continue to travel through their territory —rewarded and lived in and from the sea— identifying and recomposing their history, swimming in the waters that surround them. They do not lose hope of returning to their sea; they to continue to exist in it.   *Liliana Avila is coordinator of AIDA's Human Rights and Environment Program; Cristina Lux is an attorney with the Climate Program.  

Read more

Reserva Nacional Kawésqar, Magallanes, Chile
Indigenous Rights, Oceans

5 years of the Kawésqar National Reserve: pending issues for its protection

Local communities denounce that the area is highly affected by salmon farming, which is failing to comply with environmental regulations.On January 30, 2019, the Official Gazette published the decree creating the Kawésqar National Reserve in Magallanes, which extends over 2,842 hectares between fjords and Patagonian peninsulas. The purpose of this classification was to guarantee the protection of the area, its territory and biodiversity, as well as to establish that it is the duty of the State to ensure its conservation. This year, 2024, marks the fifth anniversary of this milestone, which begs the question: is the reserve's objective being achieved? The community's claimsWith the qualification of National Reserve, this area was separated from the Kawéskar National Park, which offers broader protection. In the opinion of the local communities, this administrative division determines in a whimsical way what to prioritize and separates the land from the sea, as if they were independent elements, which causes "divisions and confusion to grow at all levels," says Eric Huaiquil Caro, a member of the Kawésqar Communities Kawésqar Family Groups Nomads of the Sea. He also says that the "agreements that were made in the indigenous consultation have not been responded to." Finally, Caro asks that the conservation of this reserve be done "without salmon farms and we hope that this will be established in the Management Plan that will be submitted for consultation in March 2024." An overstressed areaWithin the Kawésqar National Reserve lie the richest kelp forests in the country, an ecosystem considered key to combating climate change, as they can absorb high levels of carbon dioxide and regenerate marine systems. Although the State must guarantee their protection, the area is experiencing great pressure from the salmon farming industry. For example, there are 133 approved concessions in the entire Magallanes Region and 85 in process, of which 68 approved and 57 in process are in the Kawésqar National Reserve, "which seems unusual to us because it has been proven that the salmon farming industry is neither sustainable nor compatible with the ecosystemic care of the reserve. This is fundamental to the creation of the Reserve's Management Plan, which is currently being designed and which should establish the incompatibility of the industry within the zone's protection mandate, as documented in the report we have prepared together with the communities," says Cristina Lux, an attorney with the Interamerican Association for Environmental Defense (AIDA)."Forty-three percent of the concessions approved within the Kawésqar National Reserve have presented anaerobic conditions within the framework of their operations, according to information obtained from the Environmental Reports for Aquaculture. This means that they suffer or have suffered total or partial loss of oxygen, which affects the living conditions of all of the area's biodiversity," adds Estefanía González, Campaigns subdirector at Greenpeace Chile.The impact, explains Sofía Barrera , an attorney for FIMA, is "enormous and highly destructive.""To begin with, these farming centers are concentrated in just seven sectors (Staines Peninsula, Taraba Sound, Poca Esperanza Strait and Vlados Channel, Glacier Sound, Skyring Sound, Desolation Island and Xaltegua Gulf), which also concentrates their synergistic effects. Some of these are the impact of boat routes, the killing of sea lions to prevent them from attacking the salmon cages, the overproduction of salmon, the presence of garbage outside the concession polygons and the detection of the ISA virus in the farming centers, which ends up making the rest of the marine ecosystem sick, something that has been recognized by Environmental Courts," adds Barrera. "In addition, the dispersion of organic matter from the cultivation centers causes eutrophication and harmful algal bloom events (HAB), generating significant changes in water quality and affecting marine life," adds González.In the opinion of the representatives of these three organizations, despite the legal prohibitions and environmental requirements, the fact that many of these projects have been submitted and approved through environmental impact statements raises legal and political questions. "Why are the authorities not ensuring the real care of this area, whose interests are being taken care of, and how is the salmon industry influencing our authorities," asks Barrera.Unfortunately, González adds, when explanations have been requested, "we have not received answers or certainty. That is why it is urgent to advance towards a management plan that really protects this ecosystem and does not allow more centers that put biodiversity at risk." Press contactVíctor Quintanilla (AIDA), [email protected], +521 5570522107

Read more

Oceans, Human Rights

In Chile, progress for indigenous participation in decisions affecting their territories

In January, Chile’s Supreme Court ruled that indigenous communities have the right to be informed of and participate in decisions affecting their territory and way of life. The high court ordered industrial salmon farmer Nova Austral to engage in public participation processes prior to authorizing the relocation of four farms into the Kawésqar National Reserve. The government's Environmental Evaluation Service had authorized the relocation of those farms without implementing mechanisms for consultation with the Kawésqar communities, and later rejecting their requests for public participation. It did so by arguing that the farms posed no harmful environmental impacts. The case at hand Since 2018, AIDA has been working in strategic alliance with Greenpeace Chile and FIMA to exclude industrial salmon farming from protected areas in the Magallanes Region, in the heart of Chilean Patagonia, and to defend the rights of the Kawésqar peoples, ancestral inhabitants of the area's canals and fjords. By approving the relocation, the environmental authority ignored the effects that salmon farms have had in the Los Lagos region, in the extreme north of Patagonia, demonstrating the serious risks posed by the industry's expansion into the extreme south of Patagonia, still a pristine natural area. These effects include biological contamination from the introduction of exotic species, the indiscriminate use of antibiotics, and frequent mass salmon escapes, as well as the accumulation of food and feces on the seabed, generating total or partial loss of oxygen and red tides. The environmental agency also overlooked the fact that salmon farming is incompatible with the protection objectives of the Kawésqar National Reserve, one of which is "to comply with the fundamental demands of the Kawésqar people." In fact, when the reserve was created in 2018, an indigenous consultation process chose to exclude industrial aquaculture, considering the fragility of the ecosystems of the area and the indigenous cultural legacy, closely linked to the sea. An appeal for improvement Faced with the government’s authorization of salmon farming in their territory, Kawésqar communities—with the support of the coalition formed by AIDA, Greenpeace Chile and FIMA—filed an appeal before the Supreme Court for the protection of constitutional guarantees. The judgment in favor of public participation was significant due to the fact that Chile has often been questioned for its low standard of compliance with ILO Convention 169, the most important international instrument for guaranteeing indigenous rights, including the right to prior consultation. One of the main criticisms is that the regulation for incorporating indigenous consultation into the environmental assessment encourages this not to take place. This is particularly relevant in projects evaluated by Environmental Impact Statements, for which a consultative mechanism of lesser incidence is applied and which is subject to a great deal of discretion on the part of the authority to be carried out. Moreover, in precisely those cases—including the relocation of salmon farms— public participation is not mandatory, as it is for projects evaluated by environmental impact studies. This further diminishes the possibility for communities to have their voices heard in this type of procedure. The future of participation in Chile The Supreme Court’s decision in this case is a contribution to the deepening of public participation as a tool to improve environmental decision-making. It highlights the voice of indigenous communities in matters affecting their ancestral territory. It also broadens the geographic scope of citizen participation by recognizing that these communities exercise a legitimate interest in environmental conservation, thus breaking with the idea that direct involvement depends only on their proximity to where people live. We hope that this is the first step to completely rejecting the installation of salmon farms in the Kawésqar National Reserve, in any protected area and, in general, in the seas of Chilean Patagonia.  

Read more